California has seven major architectural styles; eight if
you count Spanish. They are ranch, ranchette, rancher, American Ranch,
California Ranch, rambler and raised ranch. Seems like that anyway.
Not that there’s anything wrong with ranch-style houses. I
grew up in one and purchased two more in California. They are pure American,
born and bred. They hug the ground and favor slabs or crawl spaces rather than
basements, at least in California, a concession to the state’s propensity to
shake, rattle and roll at the most inopportune times. They are practical and
easy to build. And they are boring.
Rochester is Different
Rochester and many upstate NY cities are a different story. The Landmark Society identifies a variety of urban home styles here including Federal, Italianate, Second Empire, Queen Anne, and plenty of “Revivals,” including Colonial, Greek and Gothic. The one style that my purely unofficial observations appears to be the most prolific, at least in the Park Ave. neighborhood where I live, is a style that doesn’t appear to be a recognized as an official style at all: the American Foursquare.Foursquare Houses
Besides the extensive appearance of Foursquares in the city, I’m emphasizing this particular style for a personal reason as well. I made an offer on one of these classics the day I arrived in Rochester and was in escrow by 5 pm that evening. Like just about everything else, there are vast and important differences between buying a home here and in California.. More on the topic of home buying here, as opposed to California, in a future installment.
The Foursquare is house design became popular in the mid
1890s and continued to the late 1930s, according to Wikipedia, which describes
it as a “square, boxy design, two-and-one-half stories high, usually with four
large, boxy rooms to a floor, a center dormer, and a large front porch with
wide stairs. The boxy shape provides a maximum amount of interior room space,
to use a small city lot to best advantage. Other common features included a
hipped roof, arched entries between common rooms, built-in cabinetry, and
Craftsman-style woodwork.”
American Foursquare Design
A typical design would be as follows: first floor, from front to back, on one side, the living room and dining room; while on the other side, the entry room or foyer, stairway and kitchen. Sometimes a bathroom was also included. Second floor, front to back, on one side, bedroom, bathroom and bedroom; while on the other side, bedroom, stairway and bedroom. The bedrooms had a slightly longer dimension along the front and back of the house with side-by-side closets between the bedrooms. This gave a very efficient layout, with a bedroom in each corner and a centralized bathroom and stairway. The top floor was generally just a big open space with one to four dormers. The basement generally contained a large natural convection furnace or boiler.
More from Wikipedia:
The American Foursquare style is occasionally revived in new
developments, although its appeal is as a "traditional-looking" style
rather than a fully authentic one, often including modern 2-car attached
garages and other features absent in originals, and typically built on larger
lots.
![]() |
| An ad for an American Foursquare house from Sears Roebuck & Co. |
Mail Order Plans
The Foursquare was a popular mail-order era style along with
the California bungalow. When one was ordered, it came in a boxcar with a book
of directions and all the parts pre-cut and numbered for self-assembly. These
homes are particularly common in neighborhoods near rail-lines built in this
era. The largest mail-order house catalog companies were Sears and Aladdin.





